The land flatworm Amaga expatria Jones & Sterrer, 2005 (Platyhelminthes, Geoplanidae) was described from two specimens collected in Bermuda in 1963 and 1988 (Jones & Sterrer, 2005). It has not been recorded since. Jones & Sterrer (2005) concluded that the species was an alien species in Bermuda, probably introduced from South America since other members of the genus have been collected in this region, including Colombia, Peru, Chile, Brazil, Paraguay and Argentina (Ogren & Kawakatsu, 1990); the genus Amaga Ogren & Kawakatsu, 1990 currently includes 10 species (Grau et al., 2012).
In 2003, one of us (JLJ) undertook a citizen science program in France about alien land flatworms. Records were unexpectedly received from other locations including French overseas territories (Justine et al., 2014, 2015, 2018a, 2018b, 2019; Justine & Winsor, 2020). Among these were several records of large land flatworms from the two Caribbean islands of Martinique and Guadeloupe with similar dimensions and pigmentation to A. expatria and tentatively identified as such. To confirm this identification, one specimen from Martinique has been partially sectioned for anatomical comparison with the type material. The same specimen was also subjected to molecular sequencing (COI barcoding). Another specimen from Martinique was included in a comparative study of the mitogenome of several land flatworms (Gastineau & Justine, 2020; Gastineau et al., 2019, 2020).
We present here new records of A. expatria in two islands of the Caribbean, and provide additional morphological information, the first barcoding characterisation of the species and its complete mitogenome.
Materials and Methods
Citizen science and collection of information
Records were collected from 2013 to 2019, a period of 7 years (single records from 2006 to 2012 are also included). We used the same methods as for our previous research on land flatworms (Justine et al., 2014, 2015, 2018a, 2018b, 2019). A blog (Justine, 2019) and a twitter account (@Plathelminthe4) were the main tools for collecting and transmitting information. The collaboration of local natural history associations and of the FREDON (Regional federations for the control of pests) in the departments of Martinique and Guadeloupe was also instrumental. Reports of sightings were received from the general public and from professionals, generally by email. We solicited and obtained specimens. Specimens were obtained alive, fixed in near boiling water and preserved in 95% ethanol, or sometimes fixed directly in cold ethanol. They were sent to the Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle (MNHN) in Paris, registered and processed for molecular studies.
A specimen from Martinique, MNHN JL146, was used for histology. It was killed alive in boiling water, then kept in 80% ethanol. A portion about 1.7 cm long containing the copulatory apparatus was removed for sectioning. Horizontal longitudinal sections (HLS) were cut at 12 µm thickness, mounted on 41 slides, stained in haematoxylin and eosin and mounted in Canada balsam (slides 1–5 and 38–41 remain unstained in wax). Slides are deposited in the MNHN, Paris, registration number MNHN JL146.
For molecular analysis, a small piece of the body (1–3 mm3) was taken from the lateral edge of ethanol-fixed individuals. Extraction of DNA and PCR were performed as in previous similar works (Justine et al., 2019). Briefly, a fragment of 424 bp was amplified with the primers JB3 (=COI-ASmit1) and JB4.5 (=COI-ASmit2) (Bowles, Blair & McManus, 1995; Littlewood, Rohde & Clough, 1997), and a fragment of 825 bp was amplified with the primers BarS (Álvarez-Presas et al., 2011) and COIR (Lázaro et al., 2009; Mateos et al., 2013). PCR products were purified and sequenced in both directions on a 96-capillary 3730xl DNA Analyzer sequencer (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). Results of both analyses were concatenated to obtain a COI sequence of 903 bp in length. Sequences were edited using CodonCode Aligner software (CodonCode Corporation, Dedham, MA, USA), compared to the GenBank database content using BLAST, and deposited in GenBank under accession number MT602619–MT602626.
Next generation sequencing, phylogeny and identification of contaminant DNA
A slice of flesh from specimen MNHN JL305 was sent to the Beijing Genomics Institute (BGI) in Shenzhen, which provided DNA extraction and sequencing. Sequencing was performed on a DNBSEQ platform. A total of ca. 60 million clean paired-end reads were obtained. Reads were assembled using SPAdes 3.14.0 (Bankevich et al., 2012) with a k-mer of 85. Contigs corresponding to the mitogenome and the nuclear ribosomal RNA genes were retrieved by customized blastn command line analyses, using already available sequences downloaded from GenBank as a custom database; ribosomal RNA genes (not used in this article), were deposited into GenBank as MT860713 (18S) and MT860719 (partial 28S). In addition to the sequences related to A. expatria, other positive matches belonging to contaminant DNA were obtained as explained in the results. tRNA were identified using tRNA-scan (Lowe & Chan, 2016). The mitogenome was verified using the Consed package (Gordon, Abajian & Green, 1998), and gene identification was performed using MITOS (Bernt et al., 2013). The genomic map was drawn using OGDRAW (Lohse et al., 2013). Amino acid sequences of the protein coding genes were concatenated following a protocol already described (Gastineau & Justine, 2020; Gastineau et al., 2019, 2020), and aligned with corresponding sequences from other species using MAFFT (Katoh & Standley, 2013); we used the command-line version of MAFFT, with the option “G-INS-I”. A maximum likelihood phylogeny was inferred from this alignment using RaxML version 8.0 (Stamatakis, 2014) using the MtArt substitution model (Abascal, Posada & Zardoya, 2007). The best tree out of 100 was computed for 100 bootstrap replicates.
COI trees and distances
MEGA7 (Kumar, Stecher & Tamura, 2016) was used to evaluate distances, and construct trees. For the outgroup, we chose a sequence in GenBank from the South American species O. nungara Carbayo et al., 2016 (MN529572) which had a 100% query cover with our sequences.
Information obtained from citizen science and other scientists
We obtained 14 verified records from Martinique (map in Fig. 1), from 2006 to 2018, and six verified records from Guadeloupe, from 2012 to 2018 (map in Fig. 2). Records were generally obtained as photographs, but we also received five specimens from Martinique and three specimens from Guadeloupe (Table 1). In addition, François Meurgey (email, 29 January 2016) added information about Guadeloupe: “Amaga expatria is quite common in the high series of the mesophilic forest and between 400 and 700 m altitude in the moist forest. I met it in the municipalities of Baillif (St. Louis river), Matouba, Trois-Rivières, and Gourbeyre. It seems more frequent in the South of Basse-Terre. I have observed it attacking snails of the genera Helicina, Pleurodonte and earthworms.” Laurent Charles (email, 15 May 2020) sent a photograph showing predation on a snail identified as Helicina platychila (Von Mühlfeld, 1824).
|Date||Record (specimen number and/or photo)||Number of specimens||Commune||Department||COI sequences||Collector/observer|
|28 February 2006||Photo||0||Case-Pilote||Martinique||No||Régis Delannoye|
|17 August 2013||Photo||0||Case-Pilote||Martinique||No||Régis Delannoye|
|25 November 2013||Movie||0||Fort de France||Martinique||No||Anonymous|
|20 December 2013||Photo||0||Le Lamentin||Martinique||No||Pierre Damien Lucas|
|6 May 2014||MNHN JL146 + photo||1||Le Gros Morne||Martinique||MT602619||Clément Dromer|
|21 March 2015||Photo||0||La Trinité||Martinique||No||Régis Delannoye|
|5 August 2015||MNHN JL262||1||La Trinité||Martinique||MT602622||Olivier Palcy|
|17 October 2015||Photo||0||Le Gros Morne||Martinique||No||Pierre Damien Lucas|
|12 November 2015||MNHN JL305||1||Le Morne Vert||Martinique||MT602624*||Mathieu Coulis|
|13 November 2015||Photo||0||Ducos||Martinique||No||Cedric Rareg|
|4 February 2016||MNHN JL289||1||Le Marigot||Martinique||MT602623||Régis Delannoye|
|18 June 2017||MNHN JL310 + photo||1||Le Lamentin||Martinique||MT602625||Mathieu Coulis|
|22 June 2017||Photo||0||Fort de France||Martinique||No||Marcel Bourgade|
|27 January 2018||Photo||0||Sainte-Luce||Martinique||No||Stéphane Bras|
|12 February 2019||Photo||0||La Trinité||Martinique||No||Régis Delannoye|
|20 December 2012||Photo||0||Trois Rivières||Guadeloupe||No||Guy van Laere|
|6 December 2014||MNHN JL216 + photo||1||Gourbeyre||Guadeloupe||MT602620||Laurent Charles|
|12 December 2014||MNHN JL217 + photo||1||Bouillante||Guadeloupe||MT602621||Laurent Charles|
|21 January 2016||Photo||0||Baillif||Guadeloupe||No||Pierre et Claudine Guezennec|
|20 December 2017||MNHN JL319 + photo||1||Trois Rivières||Guadeloupe||MT602626||Guy van Laere|
|06 August 2018||Photo||0||Sainte-Anne||Guadeloupe||No||Jean-Christian Rotger|
The Table includes only observations based on photographs and specimens. François Meurgey provided additional findings in Guadeloupe: 10.10.2019, Goyave; 16.10.2019, Vieux-Fort; 22.06.2019, Petit Canal.
Morphology and histology
Description of Specimen MNHN JL146.
Living dimensions (Fig. 3): length 128 mm, width 5.5 mm. Preserved dimensions: length 108 mm, width 9 mm, height 2 mm; mouth 53%; genital pore 75%.
The copulatory apparatus (Fig. 6) is about 8 mm long from the anterior of the male system to the posterior of the female system. The male system is about 5 mm long and the female system about 3 mm long.
Two sperm ducts, about 1.2 mm apart, each with copious stored sperm (cyanophylic) approach the copulatory apparatus, briefly turn anteriorly before opening separately into the ventral end of a single duct (Fig. 6D). This duct has a thick muscular wall and runs vertically from ventral to dorsal for about 1080 µm (runs through 90 sections × 12 µm). At its dorsal end this duct continues posteriorly as a narrow sinuous duct before broadening into the ejaculatory duct. The ejaculatory duct terminates in a short penis about 800 µm long and 600 µm wide (Figs. 6A and 6B). There are atrial folds outside the penis in the common antrum.
The two ovovitelline ducts (Figs. 6A and 6B) are about 2 mm apart anterior to the penis, they run posteriorly and at about the level of the penis they turn dorsally to join and open into the combined female duct. Copious shell glands (eosinophilic) are present and open into both ovovitelline ducts before they join (Fig. 6C) to form the combined female duct. The combined female duct broadens, and has one or two longitudinal folds, before opening into the common antrum.
The gonopore opens from the common antrum via a short, narrow duct.
For four specimens, the amplified COI sequences obtained were identical along their whole length (903 bp). These specimens were JL289, JL305 (obtained both from Sanger sequencing and from the mitogenome) and JL310 from Martinique, and JL319 from Guadeloupe. This demonstrates that the same species was found in both islands. Specimen JL146 from Martinique, which was processed for histology, and three other specimens, JL216 and JL217 from Guadeloupe and JL262 from Martinique, provided shorter sequences but these were also identical between them and with the 4 sequences above for their portion in common. This demonstrates that the specimen studied for histology is from the same species, therefore confirming that the species in both islands is A. expatria. Differences with O. nungara, calculated on the 903 bp in common, were 12%.
The mitogenome (Fig. 7) is 14,962 bp long (GenBank accession number: MT527191). It contains 12 protein coding genes, two ribosomal RNA genes and 22 transfer RNA genes. The mitogenome is completely colinear with that of O. nungara (KP208777) (Solà et al., 2015) and similar in size (14,909 bp for O. nungara). A megablast query using the whole sequence of the mitogenome shows a global 83.77% identity between these two species. The mitogenome is also colinear with those of Bipalium kewense, but not with those of Platydemus manokwari and Parakontikia ventrolineata. For three genes, atp6, cox2 and ND3, it was not possible to determine the start codon. The first methionine of the predicted proteins occurs at position 72/224 for atp6, 112/260 for cox2 and 44/112 for ND3. It is worth mentioning that the impossibility to evidence a start codon for these genes was observed with O. nungara, but not for example with B. kewense, Pl. manokwari or Pa. ventrolineata. Unlike O. nungara, however, no overlap between the ND4L and ND4 genes was evidenced.
In the tree representing a maximum likelihood phylogeny of amino acid sequences of protein coding genes, A. expatria is the sister-group of O. nungara (Fig. 8).
Detection of an alien DNA
After assembly, sequences linked with contaminating DNA were identified. Three contigs of 3,080 bp, 7,274 bp and 15,202 bp were retrieved. Megablast analyses were performed on the NCBI portal. The best results are listed thereafter. The 3,080 bp fragment displayed a 99.66% of identity with the 18S ribosomal genes of sequences identified as the molluscs Subulina striatella (Rang, 1831) (MN022690), Lissachatina fulica (MN022692) and Achatina fulica (Férussac, 1821) (KU365375). The 7274 bp fragment showed a 99.97% of identity with the internal transcribed spacer 2 of a sequence identified as Subulina octona (Bruguière, 1789) (MF444887). The longest fragment appeared to be a nearly complete mitochondrial genome. The cox1 gene was extracted from it, and it showed a 97.86% of identity with S. octona (JX988065).
Amaga expatria was described on the basis of two specimens from Bermuda, the holotype, collected in 1988, and a paratype, collected in 1963 (Jones & Sterrer, 2005). The species has not been recorded since, but was mentioned in a book on molluscs of Martinique (Delannoye et al., 2015). These were originally identified by one of us (JLJ) and are also included in the present study. Our study has ten times more records than the original description, with 6 records from Guadeloupe and 14 records from Martinique (Table 1). This exemplifies again the power of citizen science for recording land flatworms (Justine et al., 2018b, 2019).
Maps (Figs. 1 and 2) show that the species is widely spread in both Martinique and Guadeloupe. In Guadeloupe, most records were from Basse Terre and a single record (Sainte-Anne) was from Grande Terre, and in Martinique, most records were from the North of the island, with only one in the South, in Sainte-Luce. This suggests that the species is more abundant in, but not exclusive to, the parts of the islands with higher rainfalls (Basse Terre in Guadeloupe and the North in Martinique).
Anatomy and morphology
The copulatory apparatus of the Martinique specimen (Fig. 6) is essentially the same as the type specimen of A. expatria from Bermuda (NHMUK.2002.10.16.1). The afferent male ducts have a similar structure, with two sperm ducts discharging into a ventro-dorsal duct which in turn opens into the ejaculatory duct and blunt penis via a sinuous duct. The duct wall is thickened in the same position about half way between the vertical duct and penis. We are confident of the identification of the Martinique specimen (MNHN JL146) as A. expatria. Given this and the similarity of the external characteristics of the specimens from Martinique, Guadeloupe and Bermuda, we are confident that all specimens are A. expatria.
Analysis of prey DNA is an efficient method to determine the diet of land planarians (Cuevas-Caballé, Riutort & Álvarez-Presas, 2019). All BLAST analyses of the contaminant DNA in a specimen of A. expatria identified it as belonging to the Gastropoda, and it is likely that the prey was a specimen of Subulina octona, or a closely related species. Subulina octona is a tropical terrestrial snail, with a cosmopolitan distribution; this mollusc is indeed present in Martinique where it is considered recently introduced (Anonymous, 2020).
The original description of A. expatria included no direct observation about the diet, but Jones & Sterrer (2005), on the basis of the presence of a plicate pharynx, wrote “it is likely that earthworms are the sole or principal prey of A. expatria”. The observations by François Meurgey (predation on snails of the genera Helicina, Pleurodonte and earthworms) and Laurent Charles (predation on Helicina platychila) reported here, and the finding of the sequence of a terrestrial mollusc in the gut, indicate a generalist diet, including both molluscs and earthworms. This diet might be one of the reasons of the success of the species to invade various islands in the Caribbean.
One specimen from Martinique was characterised for morphology, histology, and barcoding and thus represents the first attempt at a molecular characterization of the species. Specimens from Martinique and Guadeloupe provided identical sequences, therefore unequivocally demonstrating that the same species is present on both islands, and, from morphology and anatomy, is A. expatria. The absence of genetic divergence between our sequenced specimens suggests that the species was recently introduced into the two islands from a single population. The COI sequence closest to A. expatria found by BLAST was O. nungara, with a significant difference of 12%. This suggests that the COI sequences can be used for barcoding A. expatria, but this should be validated in the future by a comparative study with sequences of other species of Amaga, which are currently not available.
Mitochondrial genome and multigene phylogeny
In the maximum likelihood multigene phylogeny, the clade including A. expatria and O. nungara has a strong node support of 100, which is congruent with their position in the same Geoplaninae sub-family (Fig. 8). It clearly discriminates them from the Bipaliinae B. kewense, the Caenoplaninae Pa. ventrolineata and the Rhynchodeminae Pl. manokwari.
Among the features conserved between the mitogenomes of A. expatria and O. nungara, we would like to emphasize the conserved absence of canonical start codons for the three genes atp6, cox2 and ND3. Instead, the first amino-acids evidenced from the putative proteins are always a leucine. This leucine is always coded by a TTG codon, except for A. expatria where it is replaced by TTA. While no such thing has been evidenced among the recently sequenced mitogenomes of B. kewense, Pl. manokwari and Pa. ventrolineata (Gastineau & Justine, 2020; Gastineau et al., 2019, 2020), similar features have also been observed among several Dugesiidae such as Dugesia japonica AB618487, Dugesia ryukyuensis AB618488 (both in Sakai & Sakaizumi (2012)), Girardia sp. KP090061 and Schmidtea mediterranea NC_022448 and KM821047 (both in Ross et al., 2016). The possibility that TTG could act as an alternative start codon was already suggested by Ross et al. (2016). Based on our data, we may suggest that TTA could also be considered. Addressing properly this question might require N-terminal sequencing of these proteins.
We note that Amaga and Obama belong to the subfamily Geoplaninae, whereas Platydemus and Parakontikia are members of the Rhynchodeminae and Bipalium is a member of the Bipaliinae. This possible variation of the genetic code could thus be limited to a single subfamily within the Geoplanidae, the Geoplaninae.
Our study shows that a relatively large land flatworm species is common in two islands of the Caribbean, and, with 20 new records, adds ten times the previous number of records of the species, which were from a single location, Bermuda, an island located in the Northeast Atlantic Ocean. Jones & Sterrer (2005) hypothesized that the species originated from continental South America and was recently introduced in the Bermuda. Our genetic results show that COI sequences from Martinique and Guadeloupe were identical and thus suggest that the introduction is recent in these islands. It remains that the locality of origin of the species in South America is still unknown. The species preys on molluscs and earthworms and might be a threat to the biodiversity of soil animals, especially molluscs which include endemic and rare species in the Caribbean islands (Delannoye et al., 2015). However, no proliferation was recorded and the threat may be minor, but it might also be that A. expatria is only in the first stages of invasion and that it will become an invading species in the future; similarly, recent observations have shown that the highly invasive species Platydemus manokwari is now invading Guadeloupe (Justine & Winsor, 2020). The presence of A. expatria in two islands of the Caribbean suggests that it might be present in other islands, and perhaps in continental North America.
Complete mitogenome in FASTA format.
Complete mitogenome in Fasta format (transformed into .TXT). This is the sequence deposited in GenBank with accession number MT527191
Complete Mitochondrial Genome.
Complete mitogenome in SQN format (transformed into .TXT). This is the sequence deposited in GenBank with accession number MT527191