Visitors   Views   Downloads

Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers?

View preprint
悪徳レビュアーのブラックリスト化
88 days ago
RT @PeerJPreprints: Can editors save peer review from peer reviewers? Preprint and discussion on referee bias https://t.co/te4USF5jZP #Peer…
Can editors save peer review from peer reviewers? Preprint and discussion on referee bias https://t.co/te4USF5jZP #PeerRevWk17 https://t.co/bH5PgqXnS0
Can editors save peer review from peer reviewers? https://t.co/wMtW2ZXaLP
96 days ago
Nice article in @thePeerJ Preprints. We need someone to save #PeerReview from peer reviewers https://t.co/eg7C1NIDS6
RT @Xenpaper: Can editors save peer review from peer reviewers? https://t.co/EKBrozBEMG
96 days ago
Can editors save peer review from peer reviewers? https://t.co/EKBrozBEMG
RT @raf_dandrea: Check out my article about peer review, co-authored with James O'Dwyer: Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/La5n…
RT @JHeditor: Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/dtKn52t33A via @PeerJPreprints
171 days ago
RT @JHeditor: Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/dtKn52t33A via @PeerJPreprints
172 days ago
Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/dtKn52t33A via @PeerJPreprints
RT @caz_porter: Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/xEoGaOYTgN via @PeerJPreprints
Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/xEoGaOYTgN via @PeerJPreprints
Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/tlHS4K9LiY via @PeerJPreprints
RT @pash22: Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/ksluPu2XKW via @PeerJPreprints
RT @LeeJRickard: Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/JFgfg7iBuX via @PeerJPreprints
Good question on peer reviews. https://t.co/CUyrnwbNHD Another no one has tackled yet is how to protect ourselves from bad editors with COI.
Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/JFgfg7iBuX via @PeerJPreprints
177 days ago
Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/ksluPu2XKW via @PeerJPreprints
RT @sci_journalism: Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/Q3asp8yTGv
RT @sci_journalism: Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/Q3asp8yTGv
179 days ago
RT @sci_journalism: Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/Q3asp8yTGv
Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? https://t.co/Q3asp8yTGv
Can editors protect peer review from bad reviewers? @PeerJPreprints https://t.co/DYpPDw1ynA
RT @GrumpybaldProf: Can editors protect peer review? https://t.co/1YGX4V9lpG via @PeerJPreprints good question!!
NOT PEER-REVIEWED
"PeerJ Preprints" is a venue for early communication or feedback before peer review. Data may be preliminary.
A newer version of this Preprint is available: View the latest version

Supplemental Information

Supplementary Information

We derive the probability that a referee is selfish based on their record of reviews and disagreements.

DOI: 10.7287/peerj.preprints.3005v3/supp-1

Additional Information

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Author Contributions

Rafael D'Andrea conceived and designed the experiments, performed the experiments, analyzed the data, wrote the paper, prepared figures and/or tables, reviewed drafts of the paper.

James P O'Dwyer conceived and designed the experiments, reviewed drafts of the paper.

Data Deposition

The following information was supplied regarding data availability:

GitHub

https://github.com/odwyer-lab/PeerReviewFunctions

Funding

James O'Dwyer is supported by the Simons Foundation Grant #376199 and McDonnell Foundation Grant #220020439. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

Feedback on other revisions


Add your feedback

Before adding feedback, consider if it can be asked as a question instead, and if so then use the Question tab. Pointing out typos is fine, but authors are encouraged to accept only substantially helpful feedback.

Some Markdown syntax is allowed: _italic_ **bold** ^superscript^ ~subscript~ %%blockquote%% [link text](link URL)
 
By posting this you agree to PeerJ's commenting policies