Biological invasions are one of the most important drivers of global change and biodiversity loss (Vilà et al., 2011; Simberloff et al., 2013), and are of particular concern in aquatic ecosystems (Bunn & Arthington, 2002; Dudgeon et al., 2006) with impacts at multiple levels of organization (Simon & Townsend, 2003).
Trichocorixa verticalis (T. verticalis) (Fieber, 1851) is one of the few strictly aquatic insects that can be considered as an “alien” species (Guareschi et al., 2013), and is the only alien aquatic Hemipteran in Europe. This corixid (length <5.5 mm) is native to North America and the Caribbean islands (Tones & Hammer, 1975; Tones, 1977; Kelts, 1979; Wurtsbaugh & Berry, 1990), where it can be the dominant Corixidae species in saline wetlands (Wurtsbaugh, 1992; Aiken & Malatestinic, 1995) or even survive in the open sea (Hutchinson, 1931; Gunter & Christmas, 1959) owing to its high osmoregulatory ability (Scudder, 1976). The subspecies T. verticalis verticalis is now introduced to northwest Africa and the southwestern Iberian Peninsula, where it is often the dominant corixid in saline and hypersaline wetlands (Carbonell et al., 2017; Guareschi et al., 2013; Rodríguez-Pérez et al., 2009). Its success at high salinities is related to its osmoregulatory ability at the egg, nymph, and adult stages; its high fecundity (Carbonell et al., 2016); and the release from parasitism by water mites that infect T. verticalis at lower salinities (Sánchez et al., 2015).
In the native range, T. verticalis has been found to be an important predator in saline ecosystems, with the potential to cause major changes through trophic cascades, being one of few predators able to survive in highly mineralized aquatic ecosystems (Wurtsbaugh, 1992; Simonis, 2013). In the hypersaline Great Salt Lake (USA), the densities of T. verticalis and Artemia franciscana (Branchiopoda, Anostraca) were negatively correlated, and microcosm experiments indicated that predation by T. verticalis reduces the abundance of Artemia nauplii resulting in an increase in phytoplankton abundance (Wurtsbaugh, 1992; Wurtsbaugh & Berry, 1990). A similar trophic cascade effect of T. verticalis was observed more recently in a mesocosm experiment in which T. verticalis was predating on cladocerans (Moina macrocopa and Daphnia pulex), releasing phytoplankton from grazing (Simonis, 2013). The strength of the cascade caused by T. verticalis adults was stronger than that produced by nymphs, which are smaller and less effective as predators (Simonis, 2013). The sex of adult T. verticalis might also be expected to influence predation rates, since females are larger with higher energetic expenditure (females are 8% longer, see Results). Salinity variation may also influence predation efficiency, especially as T. verticalis and Artemia overlap in the field at the extreme upper end of the salinity range tolerated by T. verticalis (Wurtsbaugh, 1992).
Despite its abundance in saline wetlands, there is little information to date on the diet of T. verticalis, or its influence on aquatic ecosystems in the introduced range. Stable isotope studies in brackish wetlands in Doñana, SW Spain indicate that T. verticalis has an omnivorous diet with an important periphyton component, and that T. verticalis itself is an important prey for fish (Walton et al., 2015; Coccia et al., 2016b). In temporary wetlands of lower salinity where T. verticalis coexists with native corixids of a similar size (Sigara spp.), the alien often has a lower trophic niche than native species (Coccia et al., 2016a). In coastal salt pond complexes in the Portuguese Algarve and SW Spain, T. verticalis is now abundant (Sánchez, Green & Alejandre, 2006a) and has the potential to influence the abundance of Artemia spp. as recorded in the native range (Wurtsbaugh, 1992; Wurtsbaugh & Berry, 1990). Trichocorixa verticalis may have an important influence at the ecosystem level by reducing Artemia abundance below natural levels, since there is no evidence that native Corixidae were abundant in these systems, and Artemia have a strong effect on turbidity and planktonic abundance in these areas (Sánchez et al., 2016a). Furthermore, T. verticalis may represent an additional threat native Artemia, which are already being excluded from many sites by the alien A. franciscana introduced from North America for aquaculture (Amat et al., 2005).
We present an experimental study of the predation by alien T. verticalis of native Artemia parthenogenetica in the Odiel salt ponds, SW Spain. We quantify predation rates of different Artemia life stages, as a function of T. verticalis sex and salinity. We also ask how predation rates are influenced by parasitism of Artemia by cestodes. The understanding of the role of parasites in biological invasions requires consideration of how parasites affect interactions between alien species and native competitors and predators (Combes, 1996; Torchin & Mitchell, 2004; Prenter et al., 2004). Cestodes are very prevalent in native Artemia populations, with up to 12 species in the study area that use Artemia as intermediate hosts in their complex life cycles, and different aquatic bird species as final hosts (Georgiev et al., 2005; Sánchez et al., 2013; Redón et al., 2015b). Cestode parasites cause a bright red coloration and reduced fecundity in native Artemia, as well as influencing their behavior, diet and even their tolerance of contaminants (Sánchez et al., 2013; 2016b; Redón et al., 2015a). Infected individuals are more vulnerable to predation by birds owing probably to their red coloration (Sánchez et al., 2009a; 2009b), but there are no previous studies of how infection influences predation by other organisms.
Our objectives in this study were: (1) to determine which life history stages of A. parthenogenetica are predated by T. verticalis in its introduced range; (2) to analyze the differences in predation rates in relation to predator sex and experimental salinity, and how intake rates depend on prey density; and (3) to determine the influence of infection by cestodes on predation rates. We predicted that: (a) T. verticalis would preferentially predate earlier developmental stages (metanauplii and juveniles) compared to adult A. parthenogenetica; (b) predation rates would be greater at higher salinities, where T. verticalis are more likely to co-occur with Artemia in the field; (c) predation rates would be higher in female T. verticalis due to their larger size and energetic demands; and (d) Artemia infected with cestodes will be predated at a higher rate, as previously recorded for birds.
Invertebrates were collected from the Odiel salt ponds in southwest Spain (see Sánchez, Green & Castellanos, 2006b for details) during the autumn of 2013. The Junta de Andalucía provided permission to sample (P10-RNM-6262). Approximately 500 T. verticalis adults were collected using a hand net of 250 μm mesh from a pond with 25.1 g l−1 salinity (37°22′N, 07°00′W). Approximately 3,000 A. parthenogenetica individuals (of different life stages) were collected using a hand net (100 μm mesh) from a pond of 90.3 g l−1 (37°25′N, 06°99′W). All specimens were transported to the laboratory in containers filled with pondwater and submerged macrophytes. Before their use in predation experiments, individuals were kept for two days in 7 l aquaria with filtered water from the collection sites, natural substrate and artificial aeration, and were fed periodically each day (with chironomid larvae for T. verticalis and microscopic algae (Tetraselmis chuii) for A. parthenogenetica) until the beginning of the experiment. These aquaria were maintained in a climatic chamber at a temperature of 20–25 °C and a natural light schedule.
Two experimental salinities (25 and 55 g l−1) were selected based on the salinity range in which T. verticalis are recorded under natural conditions, and the range at which they are likely to encounter Artemia in the wild (Wurtsbaugh, 1992; Rodríguez-Pérez & Green, 2006; Carbonell et al., 2016). Both solutions were prepared by dissolving marine salt (Ocean Fish; Prodac®, Cittadella, Italy) in deionized water.
We conducted three different experiments (Table 1). In each replicate of each experiment, one T. verticalis individual (male: length 4.13 ± 0.001 mm, or female: 4.47 ± 0.002 mm; mean ± SE) was placed with Artemia prey in a small container (120 ml capacity) with 80 ml of saline solution, and a small plastic mesh (overall size 60 × 75 mm, mesh 10 mm) gripped easily by the corixid to allow it to rest. All experiments were conducted in a climatic chamber (20 ± 1 °C and 12 h light: 12 h dark photoperiod) with a duration of 24 h. After 24 h, we removed the T. verticalis from the container and counted the remaining prey. No T. verticalis individual was used more than once. Some T. verticalis were found dead (mortality rate = 8.2%) and these replicates were removed before analysis. After the experiment, each T. verticalis was measured to the nearest 0.01 mm and sexed by close inspection under the binocular microscope; only males have abdominal dextral asymmetry and a strigil present on the left side. Some experimental replicates were recorded on video to allow detailed observation. All statistical analyses were carried out with Statistica, v.13 (StatSoft, Tulsa, OK, USA). Furthermore, details of each experiment are provided below.
|Metanauplii and juveniles||104||733||6.476||<0.001|
|Metanauplii and adults||110||1,316.5||5.177||<0.001|
|Juveniles and adults||101||1,983||2.007||0.045|
Experiment 1: predation on different developmental stages of A. parthenogenetica
To assess selectivity, A. parthenogenetica of three developmental stages namely metanauplii (length, 3.96 ± 0.103 mm; mean ± SE), juveniles (6.42 ± 0.184 mm), and adults (7.77 ± 0.130 mm) were provided simultaneously to one adult T. verticalis. Juveniles were identified by the absence of an ovisac. In each container, we placed one predator and four individuals of each stage (a total of 12 prey). This was replicated 140 times (35 male + 35 female T. verticalis for each of the two salinities (25 or 55 g l−1). This experiment was conducted from 10/30/2013 to 11/04/2013.
For each development stage of Artemia, the number consumed were analyzed with generalized linear models (GLMs, with a Poisson error and a log link function) to test for differences in consumption rates according to salinity and T. verticalis sex. The number of each life stage consumed in each replicate were also compared using non-parametric Wilcoxon matched pairs tests.
Experiment 2: how T. verticalis predation changes with increasing abundance of adult A. parthenogenetica
Three treatments with 2, 6, and 12 adult individuals of A. parthenogenetica (length 6.92 ± 0.149 mm; mean ± SE) were applied. Each treatment was replicated 40 times (10 male + 10 female T. verticalis for each of the two salinities), making a total of 120 replicates. This experiment was carried out from 11/06/2013 to 11/09/2013. The effects of T. verticalis sex, salinity, and number of prey provided (categorical variable of three levels) on number of prey consumed (dependent variable) were analyzed with GLMs with a Poisson error and a log link function.
Experiment 3: the effects of infection by cestodes on the predation of A. parthenogenetica
Predation rates were compared for adult Artemia infected (length 7.84 ± 0.184 mm; mean ± SE) and uninfected (7.77 ± 0.130 mm) by the avian cestode Flamingolepis liguloides, which has a high prevalence in the study area in autumn (Sánchez et al., 2013). Individual Artemia were observed under the binocular microscope to check their parasitic status (infected with F. liguloides). F. liguloides is easily visible through cuticle allowing its identification under the binocular microscope (Georgiev et al., 2005). All infected individuals had a bright red color whereas uninfected shrimp remained transparent.
In each replicate, we placed one T. verticalis and two infected and two uninfected adult prey (i.e., four prey in total). A total of 130 replicates were carried out from 11/11/2013 to 11/16/2013 (30 male + 35 female T. verticalis for each of the two salinities). Differences in the number of infected and uninfected Artemia were tested using Wilcoxon matched pair tests.
Trichocorixa verticalis consumed on average 42% of A. parthenogenetica individuals of all developmental stages and parasitic states used in the three experiments, including 62% of prey in Experiment 1, 35.6% in Experiment 2, and 28.5% in Experiment 3. Direct observations and video recordings (see Additional Information and Declarations) confirmed that mortality of A. parthenogenetica was caused by predation by T. verticalis. The prey was always alive when captured by T. verticalis, which used its forelegs to grab the prey around the brood sac (for adult Artemia) or the foremost abdominal segments (for juveniles and metanauplii). Trichocorixa verticalis launched their attacks on prey from the bottom of the experimental container, or when resting on the plastic mesh, then ascended to the water surface after gripping its prey, where it pierced the cuticle and sucked out the soft tissues. Only a small part of the prey’s body remained after consumption, then was discarded.
Experiment 1: predation on different developmental stages of Artemia
Trichocorixa verticalis predated adults, juveniles and metanauplii of A. parthenogenetica (Fig. 1). There were no significant effects in GLMs of T. verticalis sex, salinity, or their interaction on the predation rates of each of the three Artemia life history stages (Wald tests P > 0.05). When sexes and salinity treatments were combined for overall matched-paired tests, the number of metanauplii predated was significantly higher than the number of adults or juveniles (Fig. 1, P < 0.0001). Furthermore, the number of adults predated was significantly higher than the number of juveniles (P = 0.045).
Experiment 2: how T. verticalis predation changes with increasing abundance of adult Artemia
The number of adult Artemia consumed by T. verticalis increased significantly with the number of prey provided (Table 2). The number predated by females was significantly higher than the number predated by males, whereas the number predated at 55 g l−1 was significantly higher than at lower salinity. Furthermore, there was a significant interaction between T. verticalis sex and salinity (Table 2). Post hoc tests with Bonferroni correction showed that the increase in predation rate at higher salinity was significant for males but not females (Fig. 2).
|Effect||Level of effect||Estimate||SE||df||Wald stat.||P|
|No. of prey supplied||2 prey||−0.914||0.108||2||72.0271||<0.001|
|Salinity||25 g l−1||−0.186||0.051||1||13.2424||0.0003|
|No. of prey supplied × sex||6 prey × male||0.283||0.108||2||6.8780||0.008|
|2 prey × female||−0.140||0.084||2.7893||0.095|
|Salinity × sex||25 g l−1 × male||−0.117||0.051||1||5.2233||0.022|
Results of a generalized linear model (GLM with a Poisson error function and log link function) with number of prey (adult Artemia) eaten by a single T. verticalis as dependent variable, and number of prey provided (2, 6, or 12 prey), T. verticalis sex and salinity treatments (25 or 55 g l−1) as three categorical predictor variables. The best model selected by AIC is presented. The overall effects of No. of prey supplied (P < 0.001) and the interaction No. of prey supplied × sex (P = 0.029) were significant. 12 prey, 55 g l−1 and female T. verticalis are aliased in the model.
Experiment 3: the effects of infection by cestodes on the predation of Artemia
Analysis of the number of Artemia adults uninfected with cestodes that were predated by T. verticalis with a GLM showed a significant increase at 25 g l−1 compared to the higher salinity, but no significant difference between T. verticalis sexes (Table 3). A similar model for the number of infected Artemia that were predated by T. verticalis revealed no influence of T. verticalis sex or salinity. The number of infected Artemia predated in each replicate was significantly higher than the number of uninfected individuals (Fig. 3; Wilcoxon matched pairs test, P = 0.000198; N = 129; T = 818.5).
|Effect||Level of effect||Estimate||SE||df||Wald stat.||P|
|Salinity||25 g l−1||0.351||0.150||1||5.464||0.0194|
Results of a generalized linear model (GLM with a Poisson error function and log link function) with number of uninfected prey eaten by a single T. verticalis as dependent variable, T. verticalis sex and two salinity treatments (25 and 55 g l−1) as two categorical predictor variables. The best model selected by AIC is presented. Salinity of 55 g l−1 is aliased. A similar model was conducted for infected prey consumed as dependent variable, and the best model contained only the intercept.
Our results confirm our expectations that T. verticalis in the introduced range (subspecies Trichocorixa verticalis verticalis) predate brine shrimps, as previously reported for another subspecies (Trichocorixa verticalis interiores) in the native range (Wurtsbaugh, 1992). We found evidence that predation rates are higher for the larger female T. verticalis, and that T. verticalis are sensitive to the number and size of their prey, to their parasitic status, and to the environmental salinity.
Our results suggest that T. verticalis readily predate A. parthenogenetica, as previously shown for A. franciscana, with which they coincide in their native range (Wurtsbaugh, 1992). In his experiments, Wurtsbaugh (1992) found a significant effect of T. verticalis on the density of nauplii larvae (P < 0.01), but not on adult density (P = 0.06). In our experiment, we found that T. verticalis had a significant preference for the smallest life stage offered (metanauplii), but they also consumed a high proportion of the adult A. parthenogenetica. In addition, we have confirmed in the laboratory that T. verticalis readily predate A. franciscana adults (V. Céspedes, 2003, personal observation).
Invasive alien species sometimes have an advantage because native prey species may not recognize them as predators (Sih et al., 2010). The fact that T. verticalis would not encounter A. parthenogenetica in their native American range seems to make no difference to their ability to recognize them as suitable prey. Even T. verticalis from other habitats in the introduced range which had no prior experience of Artemia, seem to instantly recognize native Artemia as prey, and feed readily on them in microcosms (V. Céspedes & A. J. Green, 2004, personal observation). Similarly, in a previous experimental study, fish and Odonata larvae predated T. verticalis and the native corixid Sigara lateralis at a similar rate, although Odonata larvae showed a slight preference for T. verticalis as expected from their smaller size (Coccia, Boyero & Green, 2014).
Trichocorixa verticalis has little difficulty grasping adult Artemia which they are able to roll into a ball before they start feeding (see video links in Data Availability). Although we used small experimental containers, increasing the chances of encounters between T. verticalis and Artemia, T. verticalis also actively hunt Artemia adults in larger 3.75l microcosms (see video links in Data Availability). Trichocorixa verticalis also capture and feed on live benthic chironomid larvae in the laboratory, but with more difficulty as these larvae often wriggle free. In salt ponds, chironomid larvae are an alternative prey item to Artemia, and are more abundant in ponds of lower salinity where Artemia are rarer (Sánchez, Green & Alejandre, 2006a). Copepods are also potential prey items, although it is unclear if they are important in T. verticalis diet or not (Wurtsbaugh, 1992). T. verticalis and the native Sigara corixids have similar piercing and sucking mouthparts that allow feeding on soft-bodied invertebrate prey, although they are omnivorous and feed on algae, detritus and periphyton as well as zooplankton and dipteran larvae (Kelts, 1979; Murillo & Recasens, 1986; Simonis, 2013; Coccia et al., 2016a)
Brine shrimps and other Anostracans have poor defense mechanisms against predators, and are easy prey for birds, fishes, and aquatic insects. Therefore, Anostracans rely on occupying habitats that are relatively free of predators. Brine shrimps do this by occupying habitats that are too saline for insect predators, whereas fairy shrimps typically do this by occupying temporary aquatic habitats soon after they are flooded and before they are colonized by predators. Hence the addition of a new predator such as T. verticalis, which is able to tolerate hypersaline environments, may have a considerable impact on the distribution of Artemia in the introduced range.
Our knowledge of the influence of T. verticalis on food webs and the abundance of other aquatic organisms in the introduced range is currently very limited, and restricted to a stable isotope study in lower salinity fish ponds and temporary ponds (Coccia et al., 2016a), and studies of the niche space occupied by T. verticalis and native Sigara corixids (Van De Meutter et al., 2010; Carbonell et al., 2016; 2017). This is the first study to consider the influence of T. verticalis when it invades salt pond systems occupied by Artemia. Artemia are keystone species and are the most important filter feeders in salt pond ecosystems (Sánchez et al., 2013; 2016a). In the Odiel salt ponds, field studies have shown that Artemia are low in abundance or absent in ponds of salinities below 100 g l−1 where corixids are present (Sánchez, Green & Castellanos, 2006b). Predation by T. verticalis and other predators such as the alien fish Fundulus heteroclitus is likely to restrict Artemia to ponds of higher salinities.
As we predicted, we found that the larger female T. verticalis had higher predation rates than males. The evidence we found for prey-size selection has implications for the cascading effects predation has on phytoplankton densities and dynamics (Simonis, 2013), since the filter feeding rates of Artemia increase strongly with body length (Sánchez et al., 2016a). We found significant differences in predation rates between salinities of 55 and 25 g l−1, but the results were not very consistent between experiments. In experiment 2, more Artemia adults were predated at the higher salinity, this increase being marked more for male T. verticalis. In experiment 3, more uninfected Artemia adults were predated at the lower salinity, with no salinity effect for infected prey. The lower salinity is closer to the physiological optimum for T. verticalis (Coccia et al., 2013), which is a highly abundant species in fish ponds in SW Spain of a similar salinity (Van De Meutter et al., 2010; Walton et al., 2015). It is possible that T. verticalis increased Artemia predation rates at a higher salinity as a means of compensating for the higher physiological costs of osmoregulation. The change in experimental salinity may also potentially have influenced predation rates through changes in the behavior of the Artemia prey (Sánchez et al., 2009b), for example, if uninfected prey became less active with a weaker escape response at the lower salinity.
We found that T. verticalis were more likely to predate adult A. parthenogenetica when they are parasitized by cestodes, as previously recorded for avian predators (Sánchez et al., 2009a). This may be connected with the bright red coloration of infected native Artemia (Redón et al., 2015a), owing to an increased carotenoid content (Sánchez et al., 2016b). However, it is unclear whether T. verticalis would use color as a cue, as occurs with other Heteroptera (Notonectidae, Immonen et al., 2014), and our results may perhaps have been the product of reduced mobility or escape response of infected Artemia. Preference for infected Artemia may also be associated with their higher lipid content (Sánchez et al., 2016b). Predation of infected individuals is of less significance for the reproductive rate of the Artemia population, because cestodes severely reduce the fecundity of infected individuals (Redón et al., 2015a; Sánchez et al., 2016b). This predation by T. verticalis represents a major cost to the cestode parasites since there is no chance of them completing their life cycle.
In conclusion, T. verticalis is likely to be important in invaded saline ecosystems owing to its ability to exert top down control on Artemia and other prey, causing trophic cascades. In hypersaline systems, the invasion is particularly important since native corixids were absent or rare before the arrival of T. verticalis, adding an important predator that is likely to restrict the abundance and distribution of Artemia. Future work should compare the functional responses of T. verticalis and competing native corixids when feeding on zooplankton and other prey (Dick et al., 2014), to clarify the consequences of the invasion on prey communities at lower salinities tolerated by both native and alien corixids. Given the projected expansion of T. verticalis over large areas of Europe and the Palaearctic (Guareschi et al., 2013) this alien species may have widespread impacts.