All reviews of published articles are made public. This includes manuscript files, peer review comments, author rebuttals and revised materials. Note: This was optional for articles submitted before 13 February 2023.
Peer reviewers are encouraged (but not required) to provide their names to the authors when submitting their peer review. If they agree to provide their name, then their personal profile page will reflect a public acknowledgment that they performed a review (even if the article is rejected). If the article is accepted, then reviewers who provided their name will be associated with the article itself.
World of Crayfish™: A web platform towards real-time global mapping of freshwater crayfish and their pathogens article about the open source tool, marks a significant advancement in modern conservation planning and the management of freshwater biodiversity.
[# PeerJ Staff Note - this decision was reviewed and approved by Brenda Oppert, a PeerJ Section Editor covering this Section #]
The basic reporting is clear with appropriate set up and referencing.
The aims and scope of the study are well within the framework of PeerJ and the paper makes a great addition to the literature.
This will be a solid resource that will hopefully gain traction over time and become a great resource to both crayfish folks but also conservation and freshwater researchers.
The authors have done a very nice job updating their manuscript and addressing my prior concerns.
The authors are presenting the article in a clear an unambiguous, professional English. Literature references of current article are sufficient on contextual basis. The article respect the specific structure and also contain representative tables and figures. The authors are following the current trend on relevant data sharing publishing also in increase the accessibility and availability in a digital form.
The experimental design of WoC platform is in the form of current trend in field of biodiversity platforms to increases responsibility and scientific and managerial care for species with vulnerable status. The spatial distribution at global, regional and local scales are most important to have a clear view on species state trends. Methods used for development of Webgis platform publishing like web feature services (WFS) cover needs for integrate assessment of species distribution relevant for species trend dynamics in space and time.
no comment
I want to congratulate the authors for their efforts to develop the WoC and I really appreciate the collaborative work for doing this.
Dear authors,
We kindly request that you carefully review the comments provided by the reviewers. Their valuable suggestions offer insights to enhance your manuscript. Incorporate their suggestions and carefully address all comments in your manuscript; it will significantly strengthen its content.
see attached
see attached
see attached
The World of Crayfish: A web platform towards real-time global mapping of freshwater crayfish and their pathogens article is write in a clear and unambiguous, professional English. Literature references are sufficient and description of background context is provided in clear scientific format. For the structure of article I recommend to make a distinction between Methods chapter is from line 268 to 360 and Results and discussions from 361 to 507 and it is very useful to have Conclusions to synthetize results and current and future benefits of your research.
The current article is presenting the needs of multiuser platform development for globally, regional and local, time series assessment of target species distribution. The proposed databases with spatial and temporal species distribution are organized in a web-GIS principles and can integrate data from citizen to expert integration. The research is in a Scope of the journal. The research question is well defined. The research performed is relevant & meaningful and will cover the knowledge gap related to interdisciplinarity from biologist with expertise in species identification and geoscientist with main expertise in mapping mechanism and process. To maintain the high technical standard I recommend to reformulate line 291, 436 and in Table 1 to reflect the parameters (latitude, longitude coordinate in decimal degree units, with datum WGS84) of geographic location expressed in geographic coordinate system no projection. Projection is a coordinate reference system (CRS) where the surface of the earth is projected on plan to have a common measured units like meters, kilometers and most used projection are UTM and ETRS89. Also I recommend use of OpenStreetMap like basemap not "information...projected on ..." in line 327 and 328. Methods are described with sufficient details to be replicated.
Data records and Technical validation chapters preset enough information to present the benefits of aggregated data findings and novelty of integrated analysis. Integrate of all relevant data for crayfish species distribution most of data already validated and published with local relevance are used for regional and global assessments on collaborative work platform.
The Conclusions chapter is needed.
The article is covering a relevant research and tools development for data sharing and collaborative work platform for scientific group with common interes.
Generally quite solid. I have some specific comments in my review.
Well.... difficult to comment on experimental design when there's no experiment. Maybe you guys should rename this section?
Again, satisfactory in this section.
A bit of an oddball of a MS since it's describing what is essentially a website. Saying that isn't to disparage the manuscript and especially not the website. I'm just saying that it doesn't really fit into traditional review parameters
I have a much more thorough review that will be attached as a separate file.
All text and materials provided via this peer-review history page are made available under a Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.